Thanks to Lucifurry and Ankhesen Mie for their recent comments on my posts.
Perhaps they were as surprised as I was to find out that, in 2011, gay soldiers are less controversial than undocumented immigrants.
Yes, in a final burst of lame-duck progressivism, the U.S. Congress rightfully eliminated the Don’t Ask Don’t Tell Policy at the end of 2010. As happy as I am for gay-rights activists, I feel a twinge of jealousy that about five minutes before the Senate decided to give the homophobia a break, these same people said, “But those brown-skinned kids still have to go.
Even though they were willing to deal with President Obama on just about every other piece of last-minute legislation, Republicans squashed the Dream Act as if it were a pesky mosquito.
Clearly, getting tough on illegals is still a resonant theme for the GOP. This is despite the fact that it is long-term political suicide to piss off the fastest-growing demographic in America.
The approach also ignores the fact that “Americans are more inclined to support than oppose legislation similar to the Dream Act.”
So even popular appeal is not enough to pass this most modest of reforms, which “was originally designed to be the first in a sequence of measures to resolve the status of the nation’s illegal immigrants.”
Rather than a starting point, however, the Dream Act became a flash point, proving that “in the age of stalemate, immigration may have a special place in the firmament.”
Indeed, could anyone have predicted, a decade ago, that Republicans would be more willing to say nice things about homosexuals than they are to pass immigration reform that’s actually beneficial to their big-business overlords?
And the miniscule progress that has been made will soon be wiped out, because “when Republican lawmakers take over the House and gain strength in the Senate … a decade-long drive to overhaul the immigration system and legalize some of the estimated 11 million undocumented migrants seems all but certain to come to a halt.”
The optimists among us insist that change is still possible. In fact, President Obama recently told Congressional Hispanic Caucus members that “he’ll renew his push for comprehensive immigration reform in 2011 — even though such an effort would face even longer odds in a Congress where Republicans control the House.”
But quixotic efforts aside, no one expects the issue to be resolved in time for, say, the 2012 elections. That means it will once again be open season on the undocumented (and by extension, Latinos) during the presidential campaign.
If only we were as popular and universally beloved as gay people are… yes that’s sarcasm.
January 9th, 2011 on 6:52 am
I saw the effects of the (lack of) Dream Act first-hand while coaching sports at a small urban university in Chicago. The neighborhood surrounding the university was predominantly recent immigrants–not only Latinos, but also people from many Asian and African countries. More than once, I worked with high school recruits who wanted to study and play sports at the university but in the end, they could not. Their parents hadn’t come to the U.S. legally, and there was no way for the students to receive ANY financial aid. It was heartbreaking.
January 9th, 2011 on 11:32 am
Honey, they’re thinking, “At least some gay people are white.” And sure…they’ll help out some of their own. ‘Twas not a fabulous cast of color we saw on Will & Grace, and they lived in New York.
But brown is brown is brown. And brown can’t stick around, not according to the GOP. Even if some of the brown folks in questions have been around since before the arrival of the vaunted forefathers.
July 5th, 2011 on 8:09 am
Thick-headed is thick-headed is thick-headed. We ALL come from immigrants. How can anyone, however, celebrate any illegality involved in immigration? It’s so difficult for me to understand this. If someone arrives here ‘under cover of night’, it’s clearly breaking the law. These are not people concerned with laws, citizenship, American loyalty, contributing to the economy (need to send money ‘home’, right?), or involving themselves in uplifting this country. There are other very good reasons to discourage illegal entry – health, crime, overcrowding, cost – I am sickened by the CONSTANT accusation that it’s because of color. Is that supposed to distract from the real issue? Because, it doesn’t hold even a drop of water. It’s NOT color. My grandparents came from many different countries – legally, proudly, and willingly. Why can’t it be understood that there’s a right way and a wrong way to arrive here? There’s not a piece of fruit that doesn’t get in without being inspected!! It’s ridiculous to expect every benefit this country has to offer, without so much as an ID card. I think it’s about time we get off the pity train and step into reality. Too many things go wrong when you start out dishonestly. I find it insulting, as a grandchild of very, very proud immigrants, to be diminished, yet again, by the ‘race cliche’. Pathetic. Oh, and btw – try getting into ANY other country illegally…